The Gospel Coalition’s Board of Directors stated they were informed by Sam Allberry about “an inappropriate relationship with another man a few years ago” just before his resignation announcement at Immanuel Church on May 4, 2026.
Allberry, a well-known pastor and author—famed for works like “Is God Anti-Gay?”—has openly discussed his experience with same-sex attraction throughout his ministry. His resignation comes as a shock to many in the Christian community, particularly given his previous role as a speaker and leader within The Gospel Coalition.
In the wake of this revelation, the elders at Immanuel Nashville decided to disqualify him from ministry. They believed that maintaining the integrity of their church was paramount. The emotional weight of this decision ripples through the congregation and beyond.
The following actions have been taken:
- The Gospel Coalition removed all of Allberry’s content from its website and social media channels.
- Support has been extended to Immanuel Church and those affected by this news.
- Allberry’s past discussions on same-sex attraction have become a focal point in conversations about faith and sexuality.
In a statement, The Gospel Coalition expressed their heartbreak over Allberry’s situation: “We are heartbroken over this news, and we continue to pray for Sam, Immanuel Church, and everyone affected.” Their sentiment reflects the broader community’s struggle with reconciling faith and personal failings.
Allberry grew up in England and embraced Christianity at 18. His journey has been marked by a commitment to his faith, yet this recent development raises questions about the complexities of same-sex attraction within the church.
As the dust settles, there’s a palpable sense of loss—both for Allberry’s contributions to the ministry and for the community that looked to him for guidance. The next steps for Allberry remain uncertain; no timeline has been shared regarding his future endeavors or potential return to ministry.